11 January 2010

Beating A Dead Recall.

Alas, we've been over this before, dear readers. But even after a legal opinion by the State's Attorney General determining a recall is unconstitutional, and a letter from the Secretary of State's office saying that they will not proceed with any recall vote, the folks attempting to recall Mary Landrieu are still at it.

This is quickly going from an honest, if misguided, venting of frustration to a quixotic farce that will come back to tarnish the Tea Party movement. Without any weight of Law or legal precedent on their side, the proponent's rationale for continuing this now appears reduced to a legal syllogism at the adolescent level: Since the Constitution doesn't specifically forbid a recall, it must be constitutional.

True, the Constitution doesn't specifically forbid a recall. But by that same logic, since the Constitution doesn't specifically forbid an individual mandate to purchase insurance, must it therefore be constitutional? I mean, that's basically the Left's constitutional argument for ObamaCare.

How can we claim to be the ones defending the letter, spirit, and intent of the Constitution against the grasping-at-clauses rationale of the the Left, if we are doing the very same thing when it suits us? It makes our side look like hypocrites, or worse - like we don't even understand the very document we claim to be defending.

I don't know Mr. Ruben T. Leblanc, so I don't want to judge his motives. While misguided, he seems earnestly fed up with the politics-as-usual in DC - as are we all. But this approach is a legal dead end, a potential public relations plus for our opponents ("See, the Tea Parties claim to be defending the Constitution, but don't even understand how it works!..."), distracts us from our true objectives this year, and gives our supporters false hope in something that isn't real.

Mr. Leblanc better have some whopping deep pockets and a lot of time if he wishes to proceed with a "legal battle Royale" over this issue. Lawyers ain't cheap. As I've said before, the Tea Party Movement needs to focus on 51%-plus solutions in 2010, not 3.79% solutions.

UPDATE 12JAN10: Cross-posted over at The Hayride.

10 January 2010

To My New Orleans Friends.

Have a listen to this. And why is John Georges so interested with who is the current US Attorney?

Hattip: The Hayride.

09 January 2010

Rules For Me, Not For Thee.

Massachusetts Democrats say that if Republican Scott Brown wins Ted Kennedy's old Senate seat, which is looking like more and more of a possibility, they will drag on the certification process if he wins so he can't vote against ObamaCare:
The U.S. Senate ultimately will schedule the swearing-in of Kirk’s successor, but not until the state certifies the election.

Friday, a spokesman for Secretary of the Commonwealth William Galvin, who is overseeing the election but did not respond to a call seeking comment, said certification of the Jan. 19 election by the Governor’s Council would take a while.

“Because it’s a federal election,” spokesman Brian McNiff said. “We’d have to wait 10 days for absentee and military ballots to come in.”

Another source told the Herald that Galvin’s office has said the election won’t be certified until Feb. 20 - well after the president’s address.
The election is 19 January. Funny, when they needed a Massachusetts Democrat vote, none of that seemed to matter:
In contrast, Rep. Niki Tsongas (D-Lowell) was sworn in at the U.S. House of Representatives on Oct. 18, 2007, just two days after winning a special election to replace Martin Meehan. In that case, Tsongas made it to Capitol Hill in time to override a presidential veto of the expansion of the State Children’s Health Insurance Program.
You know it's bad when even Hillary fans are crying foul.

LOLcats For People.

If you ever wondered where those posters come from, now you know: Very Demotivational Posters. (Note: NSFW)

My favorite (that I can safely post):

Smile Bear!

Hattip: Vodkapundit.

08 January 2010

Fear Of Flying.

ReasonTV makes an honset TSA ad.

Ethics Quiz.

QUESTION 1:
There is a debate raging over implementing a certain government policy. You conclude that the claims by the side opposed the policy are, well, full of Landrieu - and you say so in public. Repeatedly. Your arguments carry great weight in the mind of the public and the press because you are an academic - an impartial and learned observer.

But you are also getting paid a tidy sum in public funds, under contract, to advise that same government on that policy. You should:

A) disclose this apparent conflict of interest up front.
B) say nothing knowing the press won't check.

Apparently, these days the answer is 'B'.

BONUS QUESTION:
You are the head of the government administration paying for the above contracts. In support of your policy of having the most ethical and transparent administration in US history, you should:

A) disclose this apparent conflict of interest up front.
B) say nothing knowing the press won't check.

See the answer to the first question.

Its the Chicago Way.

07 January 2010

Another Massachusetts Miracle?

We used to live in Boston, and I remember when a Republican was a viable US Senate candidate if they got 25% of the vote. But with no Kennedy in the race, and Bay State voters growing sick of 'RomneyCare' - their version of ObanaCare complete with individual mandates, fines, public options and spiraling costs - this race is getting veeeery interesting. The GOP candidate, State Senator Scott Brown, has closed the gap with the Democrat candidate to single digits, and is now hotter than a Nigerian's crotch on final approach to Detroit.

Can Brown win? A tossup. But in order to make the point he doesn't have to. If an anti-Team Hopenchange Republican candidate can do this well in uber-blue state Massachusetts, where they've already seen the fruits of ObamaCare, what does this say about what will happen in November in fly-over country if ObamaCare passes? At a minimum, a Brown almost win should slow ObamaCare's pace in Congress, hopefully to die alone in a cloak room in a few months, or cause enough Dems in the house and Senate to change their votes and kill it outright. And if he wins? Well...

Baton Rouge Retrospective.

Via Abandoned Baton Rouge comes this link with lots pictures and postcard images of Baton Rouge from the 30's thru the 80's.

This one's for you, Ruth.

Bishop Charles Jenkins Retires.

Story is here. As Bishop of the Diocese of Louisiana, Charles Jenkins has been an enigmatic figure to say the least, and will likely be the last remotely orthodox Bishop we will have in my lifetime (if ever). The debates about whether Charles was overtaken by events, or just not up to them, is now moot. I wish he and Louise well in their retirement.

A Personal Note.

If you send me emails about the USDA declaring a disaster so they can secretly put chemicals in our food to control our minds, and you are about to "expose" this "truth" to the world, please remember that there is more to "research" than Google.

Today's my birthday. I'm too damn old to suffer paranoid fools gladly anymore.

06 January 2010

How To Write Like An Arcitect.



This YouTube channel could have saved me loads of time. And my parents thousands.

Hattip: Sippican Cottage. Read Sippican's commentary at the post. "He thought I was freaking Merlin." How true.

05 January 2010

The System Works. (UPDATED)

Michael Yon, this generation's Ernie Pyle, says he was detained at the Seattle airport for... failing to disclose his income.

Good 'effing grief. Isn't this the same bunch that missed a Nigerian jihadi trying to blow a hole in a plane - and splatter passengers with bits of his scrotum in the process - but now they arrest a US Citizen trying to get into his own country???

What, by the Gods, does Mr. Yon's income have to do with national security? The correct answer is, of course, not a damn thing.

I'm going to be flying in a few weeks, and if you think I feel safe and secure in the knowledge that Homeland Security has got my back, you're wrong. I dread the long lines, the annoying checks and rechecks, and the rude, lethargic, and pushy TSA gate guards who are only half gazing at the x-ray readout. They couldn't give a rat's ass about me or my safety.

As far as I am concerned, we should scrap TSA entirely. Let 'em all go back to whatever fast-food restaurants they came from. At least there we got something out of them for our money.

UPDATE: More here.

Tilting At Recalls.

With Senator Mary Landrieu (D - For Sale) doing her best to participate in Harry Reid’s recent ‘Cash for Cloture’ program and voting to place one sixth of our economy under direct government control, a lot of people here in Louisiana - including a lot of Tea Party folks - have been demanding her recall.

A great emotional sentiment; but legally, it’s not that easy. While Landrieu, Reid, Pelosi, and their Lefty comrades are busy trying to shred our Founding Document to create their Euro-government paradise, we in the Tea Party Movement are in the vanguard of protecting the Constitution and the Rule of Law - even when it doesn’t go our way.

And in this case, it doesn’t.

The Constitution has a thing or two to say about who can boot out a sitting Representative or Senator. Article I, Section 5 is quite clear:
Each House shall be the judge of the elections, returns and qualifications of it’s own members…
and goes on to say in the next paragraph:
Each House may determine the rules of it’s proceedings, punish members for disorderly behavior, and, with the concurrence of two thirds, expel a member.
In other words, the Constitution gives the respective Houses of Congress alone the power to set further qualifications for their members, or remove the same. This has been the understanding of the Article I, Section 5, language since the Constitution was ratified, and the Courts have consistently concurred.

Some have argued that since Article I, Section 4 gives the States the power to set “the times, places, and manner of holding elections for Senators and Representatives…”, then all of a State’s election laws must apply to all Senators or Representatives from that State – including a State’s recall law if they have one (Louisiana has one). But this Constitutional language only delegates to the States how the elections occur. Once elected, Senators and Representatives are Federal officials subject to the Constitution - not state laws.

And the Tenth Amendment? The Supreme Court has concluded, U.S. Term Limits, Inc. v. Thornton, 514 U. S. 779 (1995) and Cook v. Gralike, 531 U.S. 510 (2001), that the Tenth Amendment does not reserve to the states the power to put further qualifications on Senators and Representatives, as that power was specifically delegated to the Congress. As Federal Officials, the offices of Senators and Representatives "arise from the Constitution itself", not various individual state laws.

Therefore, only Constitutional provisions apply to the tenure of Senators and Representatives, and a State may not qualify that further. It is, and has been, settled Law.

Would a legal challenge to 223 years of Constitutional understandings and precedent work to remove Landrieu? Highly doubtful. While the question of 'recall' has never been specifically adjucicated (a major claim by proponents for the constitutionality of a recall), the questions concerning the division of powers in the Constitution that a recall would raise have been clearly and consistantly answered - and they do not favor finding a recall constitutional. As a practical matter, it would require someone with a lot of time, a lot of disposable income, and standing to make the challenge. They would need to raise a constitutional question unique enough to make its way through the Courts, for SCOTUS to grant cert, and then find in favor of the constitutionality of a recall. That's a lot of "ifs" before any recall could take place. By that time Landrieu would likely be up for reelection.

The demand to recall Mary Landrieu is not the only one in Louisiana in 2009. Back in the beginning of the year an attempt to recall Joseph Cao (R-New Orleans) got a lot of press after he opposed Obama’s Stimulus Package. But it has gone nowhere because, in the words of the recent opinion by the Louisiana State Attorney General (09-0015):
In conclusion, a member of Congress is neither a state officer nor local officer and therefore is not subject to recall pursuant to La. R.S. 18:1300.1, et seq.

The United States Constitution has delegated to Congress the power to determine the qualifications of its own members and expel its members when necessary. Since this is a power reserved for the individual Houses of Congress, the tenth amendment of the United States Constitution does not reserve to the states the authority to remove members of Congress from office.

Neither the Secretary of State, Registrars of Voters for the Parishes of Orleans and Jefferson, nor Governor Jindal would be required to proceed with the recall process set forth under Louisiana law. These offices only have jurisdiction over a recall attempt of a public officer as defined under Louisiana law. This definition does not include officers acting under the authority of the United States.
I contacted the Secretary of State's Office yesterday (4 January) about petitioning to recall a Federal elected official under Louisiana law, and confirmed with them that the Attorney General's opinion will control their actions if any petition is filed. In other words, no recall election will be called by the Secretary of State's office.

So in the end, as much as we wish it to be otherwise, any 'Recall Mary' petitions gathered and presented to the the Secretary of State's Office would go nowhere, and any court challenge would take years with almost no chance of success. Attempting a recall would take up a lot of our time, our money and our effort, and would distract us from winnable issues that will resonate with a majority of voters in 2010. If we want to change things we need to focus on 51%-plus solutions, not 3.79% solutions. The best way to remove Mary Landrieu's power now is to make her a member of the minority party in the Senate in January 2011, or at a minimum, remove the 60-seat majority in the Democrats enjoy in the Senate.

04 January 2010

Happy Birthday, Norris!

Another year younger!

And Now For Something Completely Different.

The three stages of Communism: first Marxism, then Lenninism, and finally....

Weird Al Yankavism:



From here.

03 January 2010

Give A Little Bit.

Or, if you're a typical greedy, uncaring, uncompassionate, consumerist capitalist American, you give a lot. A helluva lot.

Which made me think - what about my church? Well, let's take a look at the Episcopal Church Foundation. Here is their mission statement. And here is their CharityNavigator.org rating.

One star.

That's right, one bloody star. Which, according to CharityNavigator.org, means, "POOR. Fails to meet industry standards and performs well below most charities in its Cause."

Episcopal Relief and Development, however, does rather better: Four stars.

Speaking Truth To Narrative.

Also via Instapundit, 'Armed Liberal' over at Winds of Change reviews a review of 'The Blind Side'.

Priorities, Priorities.

Via Instapundit, what is important to Team Hopenchenge becomes apparent:
"It speaks eloquently to the Obama administration’s priorities that it took the White House four days to acknowledge the “catastrophic breach of security” that led to the failed bombing of a US-bound jet on Christmas Day — but a scant four hours to accuse Dick Cheney of coddling terrorists."
What? Like you thought we were the focus? Pshaw!

01 January 2010

La Dolce Vita, Cher.

Via Instapundit, here's a blog a blog by a Cajun living in one of my favorite places: Coonass In Italy.

Check it out!

Let's Start Off The New Year With Some Good News.

As Emily Litella used to say, "Oh. Nevermind"...